Letting ISPs retire copper lines and move to next-generation technologies is critical to broadband deployment, industry experts said during a USTelecom forum Thursday. FCC Chairman Brendan Carr has said repeatedly that the agency wants to make it easier for ISPs to modernize their networks (see 2504030011). Other executives warned that uncertainty in the BEAD program could be slowing broadband deployment.

The Senate Commerce Committee advanced NTIA administrator nominee Arielle Roth on a nearly party-line vote of 16-12 Wednesday, as expected (see 2504080059). Sen. John Fetterman of Pennsylvania was the only Democrat to buck his party by supporting her move forward. Panel Democrats gave Republican FCC nominee Olivia Trusty a more positive reception during her Wednesday confirmation hearing, even as they used some of their questions to hammer commission Chairman Brendan Carr’s actions since he took the gavel Jan. 20 and renew their concerns about the loss of agency independence during the Trump administration (see 2504090060).

Communications policy-focused lobbyists and other observers expect most Senate Commerce Committee Democrats will vote against advancing NTIA administrator nominee Arielle Roth on Wednesday, they told us. Democrats’ criticism of Roth won't ultimately threaten her prospects, though, as observers said they expect Senate Commerce Republicans to almost uniformly support her. Senate Commerce's meeting to vote on Roth will begin at 10 a.m. in 253 Russell. Lawmakers and observers said they expect Democrats to be equally, if not more, critical of Republican FCC nominee Olivia Trusty during a confirmation hearing that will immediately follow the Roth vote (see 2504080066).

WISPA President David Zumwalt on Friday called for changes to the BEAD program's rules to make it technology neutral. Zumwalt said the Biden administration wrongly put too much focus on fiber in developing the rules. “The mission of serving the unserved can be met with the tools that we have in place, with the service providers we have in place,” he said. “There’s no need to continue the nonsense that was put into the BEAD program from the beginning.”

With West Virginia's announced pause of its BEAD process as it revamps its state program to be more in line with what the White House wants, some other states are expected to follow its lead, observers told us. There have been numerous indications that big changes are ahead for BEAD rules (see 2503200003).

More than 100 state legislators from 28 states on Thursday urged Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick and NTIA to ensure that states have the final say over their BEAD programs. In a letter backed by the Benton Institute for Broadband & Society, the bipartisan group of lawmakers raised concerns about reported changes to the program that could cause delays to broadband deployment and states' authority over state programs. As of Thursday, 115 lawmakers had signed the letter and encouraged others to sign.

While FCC Chairman Brendan Carr has indicated that the agency envisions more steps to retire copper networks, beyond a series of orders issued in March, we're told it's unclear what big regulatory burdens remain. The agency last month called its steps "initial" and promised additional action (see 2503200056). Carr used similar language at last week's FCC meeting (see 2503270042). His office didn't comment further.

USTelecom warned that changes to pole attachment rules could harm broadband deployment under the BEAD program. In a filing posted Wednesday in docket 17-84, USTelecom cited recent filings by ACA Connects (see 2503110021), electric utilities and others. USTelecom members “are working to deploy broadband as quickly as possible and support Commission efforts to speed such deployments, including those funded through BEAD and other government programs,” the group said. “However, departing from the negotiated timelines required under the Commission’s current rules and adopting one-size-fits-all make-ready timelines for large make-ready orders will not speed deployment in BEAD or otherwise.”

The following are short summaries of recent CBP NY rulings issued by the agency's National Commodity Specialist Division in New York:

Senate Commerce Committee ranking member Maria Cantwell of Washington and several more panel Democrats indicated Thursday that they are undecided or may vote against NTIA nominee Arielle Roth amid frustration over the nominee's responses to questions about how she plans to revamp the agency’s $42.5 billion BEAD program. Senate Commerce Chairman Ted Cruz of Texas and other committee Republicans signaled during the sparsely attended hearing that they strongly back Roth, who has been their telecom policy director. Republican and Democratic Senate Commerce members used the hearing to sound off on the Biden administration’s handling of BEAD and reemphasize their positions on protracted negotiations on a potential spectrum legislative package, as expected (see 2503250055).